Products

X-Men Star Nicholas Hoult Missed Out On Doctor Who Role

By Cameron K McEwan

Actor/writer Mark Gatiss has been chatting exclusively to Doctor Who Magazine about his Doctor Who career, including the numerous stories he has written and starred in.

EXCLUSIVE OFFER: Save 46% On Digital DWM Subscription

DWM 515, out tomorrow, spoke to Mark about his 2006 episode, The Idiot's Lantern, starring David Tennant as The Tenth Doctor and Billie Piper as Rose Tyler; he said:

“It was amazing to have David, because he was my friend and he was the Doctor."

Gatiss told DWM that, originally, a different actor was chosen for the role of Tommy, the writer remarked:

"I also remember Nicholas Hoult was going to play that part, but we couldn’t get the licence to work because he was too young! But Rory Jennings who played Tommy was wonderful, and he was actually a lot older than he looked.”

Hoult shot to fame starring alongside Hugh Grant in the 2002 film, About A Boy, and went to further acclaim in TV shows such as C4's Skins and BBC's Wallander, and as Hank McCoy (aka Beast) in the movies X-Men: First Class, X-Men: Days of Future Past and X-Men: Apocalypse. The BAFTA-nominated actor also starred prominently in the OSCAR-winning Mad Max: Fury Road.

Tommy from The Idiot's Lantern

Gatiss also recalls the character of Tommy (pictured above with the Tenth Doctor and Rose) was gay in the initial scripts:

"Oh, I do remember something very, very, very vividly: in the early drafts the boy Tommy is gay and he has a crush on the Doctor. Rose thinks he’s interested in her, then goes ‘Oh!’ and realises Tommy’s been talking about the Doctor all along.

And the Doctor has to have a quiet word with him. When they get back in the TARDIS, Rose says something like, ‘It’s quite sweet isn’t it – obviously you wouldn’t be interested’. And the Doctor plays Don’t Fence Me In by Cole Porter, like James Bond saying, ‘What makes you think it’s my first time?’ [A reference to a scene in 2012's Skyfall.]

I thought it’d be nice to have the Doctor telling Rose not to make any assumptions about him."

Finally, another revelation from the DWM interview tells us that when Mark began to write The Idiot's Lantern it was, in fact, for Christopher Eccleston's Doctor:

"I wrote the first draft for Chris and Billie [Piper, who played Rose], so somewhere there’s a Ninth Doctor version."

Doctor Who Magazine 515

Doctor Who Magazine 515 is available from July 27, 2017

More on Products

Sorry there is no content available for your region.

more from the whoniverse

Explore

Show Info

Explore

Stories

Explore

Play

More From Read and Watch

Arthur Darvill on Rory's reunion with River Song

16 Sep 2026

Ahead of their return in a new series of audio adventures, Arthur Darvill speaks to Doctor Who Magazine about his character's timey-wimey relationship with his daughter...

DWM 634
Features

A Brief History of the Doctor's Sonic Screwdriver

4 Sep 2026

Everything you need to know about the Doctor's most trusted gizmo...

Fugitive Doctor sonic
Features

Waris Hussein and Carole Ann Ford on working with William Hartnell

27 Aug 2026

The series' first ever director and the Doctor's original companion reminisce together in a new episode of The Whoniverse Show...

Whoniverse Show
Features

David Tennant on the Tenth Doctor's adventures with Rani Chandra

14 Aug 2026

Doctor Who Magazine speaks to David Tennant about stepping back into his old trainers in a new series of Big Finish audio adventures...

David Tennant and Anjli Mohindra
Features

First look at Circuit Breaker story 'The Honourable Society'

20 Jul 2026

The Fugitive Doctor's adventure continues in the pages of this month's Doctor Who Magazine...

Sontaran villain wearing a read hooded cloak
Features

from the store

More from the store

Circuit Breaker 

Momento Mori

Coming 27.08.2026 to Doctor Who: Lost in Time

Not available in your area

Circuit Breaker Product 9
Circuit Breaker

Circuit Breaker 

The Doctor and the Three Witches

Coming 20.08.2026 to Puffin Books

Not available in your area

Circuit Breaker Product 8
Circuit Breaker

Circuit Breaker 

Don't Blink!

Coming 17.08.2026 to UNIT HQ

Not available in your area

Circuit Breaker Product 7
Circuit Breaker

Circuit Breaker 

Castling

Coming 06.08.2026 to Doctor Who: Lost in Time

Not available in your area

Circuit Breaker Product 6
Circuit Breaker